Posted by: Debbie | September 1, 2011

Is a Vegan Diet Worse for the Environment than an Animal Based Diet?

Recently I ran across a few articles and posts that claim a vegetarian diet is actually worse for the environment than the diet of a meat eater! Shocking and also very misleading. So I thought I’d look into each one of the arguments over the next few posts.

The argument usually goes like this:
1. It takes more land to grow all those vegetables than animal farming
2. More animals are displaced and bugs killed due to the growing of more vegetables
3. Importing vegetarian foods like tofu and plant based meats uses more resources than eating animal meat

I’ll start with the argument that it takes more land to grow all those veggies.

Ok, so let’s think about this. It takes 2.6 pounds of feed to produce one pound of beef, and it takes approximately 2 pounds of feed for every pound of chicken. So this would indicate that it takes on average over 2x the amount of farmed land to feed farmed animals than what it would take for a veggie diet.

Yes, I can hear you saying that animals are not fed only plant based food so this assumption of over 2x is not correct. Yes, it is very true and very, very sad that farmed animals do not only eat plants. The factory farming industry has made farm animals cannibals. Below is the list of ingredients such as animal waste, rendered animals, and chemicals that are added to what is fed to the various factory farmed animals that people eat. Please note that this reference is not from an animal rights site but from the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences. While not everything a farmed animal eats is grain, the vast majority of it is or it is from an rendered animal that was also on a similiar diet. So I don’t think we can claim that because not everything a farmed animal eats is grain the ratio of food to meat is exaggerated.

Animal Feed Ingredients and Feeding Practices:
Rendered animal products
Animal Waste
Plant- and Animal-based Fats
Antibiotics
Metals
Biological, Chemical and Other Etiologic Agents Detected in Animal Feed
Bacteria
Antibiotic-resistant bacteria
Prions
Mycotoxins
PCDDs, PCDFs, and PCBs

So if it takes about 2x as much to produce one pound of food from animals than it does from plants, and even though the food given to animals is not totally plant based, it is hard to argue that a vegan diet takes more land than a diet based on the slaughter of animals.  And besides, does anyone really want to eat somthing that has eaten PCBs and rendered animals?

About these ads

Responses

  1. Thanks for that list of farmed animal feed ingredients. That makes it clear that eating meat is a lot like scavenging a hospital trash can. Marketing and steak sauce blind us to these things.

    • It is pretty sick isn’t it? Makes me think twice about ever kissing a meat eater on the mouth again :)

  2. Vegetarian foods are the best since they are low in fat and are healthier. *

    <a href="Please do have a look at our own webpage
    http://www.healthmedicinelab.com/appendicitis-in-children/

  3. Vegetarian meals do not deviate much from a regular diet except for the absence of meat. Skeptics argue that this could mean missing out on essential proteins. But this is hardly true nor correct. All healthy vegetarian recipes are well-balanced. They have the required amounts of essential vitamins, minerals, and protein. Examples of protein choices are legumes, nuts, beans, fish, poultry, dairy, and the popular tofu. Calcium, a mineral often associated with milk, is not missed either. Middle Easterners and native Africans are known to have strong teeth and bones but their diets rarely contain dairy or meat. They get their calcium from vegetables and root crops. So there is no reason you couldn’t get your calcium requirements from vegetarian foods. In terms of nutrition, a vegetarian diet is even superior to diets with meat. There is less fat and bacteria that enter the body which can cause heart diseases and infections. You can watch meat lover bloat and get fat while maintaining your own healthy body.*

    Our new web portal
    <'http://www.healthmedicinecentral.com/


Questions, comments, concerns?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 159 other followers

%d bloggers like this: